It will come as NO surprise to anyone who reads this, that I’m a trekkie. (I don’t do the whole trekkie/trekker debate, I am what I am) Since I saw the pilot to Star Trek the Next Generation back in 1988. I love the utopian vision of a humanity that has got it’s shit together. I love the tech, the stories and the scope of what tales can be done. But it’s not 1966 any more and sometimes people want to update some things, hence 2009’s Star Trek by J.J. Abrams. This film recast the characters from the original series with current/younger actors including Bruce Greenwood as Captain Christopher Pike, Chris Pine as James T Kirk, Zachary Quinto as Spock, Karl Urban as Dr. Leonard ‘Bones’ McCoy, Zoe Saldana as Nyota Uhura, John Cho as Hikaru Sulu, Simon Pegg as Montgomry Scott and the late Anton Yelchin as Pavel Chekov. There was also non-crew casting of Ben Cross as Sarek, Winona Ryder as Amanda Grayson, Eric Bana as Nero, Rachel Nicholas as Gaila, Jennifer Morrison and Chris Hemsworth as Kirk’s parents and Leonard Nimoy as an older Spock.
Plot: In the 23rd Century, Earth is part of the United Federation of Planets, exploration and peacekeeping are handled by Star Fleet. One ship, the USS Kelvin encounters a huge Romulan ship, captained by a man calling himself Nero. Nero disables the Kelvin and demands it’s captain come across in surrender. Nero is looking for a man called Ambassador Spock, when the captain admits he doesn’t know, he is killed, leaving Lt. Kirk in command. Kirk orders an evacuation, including his wife who is in the midst of labour. Lt. Kirk then flies a suicide run to disable the other ship, long enough to cover the evacuation, born on one of the shuttles is Kirk’s son, who he lives long enough to name, James. Years later, on Vulcan, we see a half human/half vulcan called Spock, struggling to assimilate both sides of himself and eventually decides to leave his home and join Starfleet, rather than deal with the near-racist sneers from his father’s people.
We then meet James later, a smart, but angry child who grows into an angry adult, who’s met by Christopher Pike, a captain in Starfleet, who points out that Kirk’s father was captain of a ship for only minutes and saved hundreds of lives, he dares Kirk to do better. So, on a dare an angry James T Kirk joins Starfleet along with a friend he makes on the shuttle there, Dr Leonard McCoy.
3 Years later and over 20 years since the Kelvin incident and Kirk is in his final days at Starfleet Academy, when he takes the unbeatable Kobiashi Maru test, when he beats it, he has to face it’s designer when accused of cheating, that’s when he meets Spock. Then Vulcan is calling for help. The graduating class are all put into service, being assigned to ships, except Kirk, but he’s sneaked onto the flagship ,the USS Enterprise (where Uhura, Chekov and Sulu are already serving) by Bones. When he wakes he tries to warn the ship that they’re heading into a trap, since the reports are identical from the day he was born. Nero has come to Vulcan. By being late in leaving, the Enterprise is spared the massacre committed on the rest of the fleet and Nero again calls the captain to negotiate a surrender. Pike gets Spock to take command and puts Kirk in the number 2 spot. The mission goes badly and using some illdefined tech, Nero destroys Vulcan. Spock saves as many as he can, but while he saves his father and many of the elders, he loses his mother. Things fall apart further as Nero leaves and Kirk wants to go after him, knowing that Earth may be his next stop. Spock removes Kirk and abandons him on a nearby planet. On this nearby planet, Kirk meets the older Spock, who explains the plot. Near the end of the 24th Century, Romulus’ sun explodes, Vulcan sent their fastest ship along with the gravity altering red-matter (the same stuff that just destroyed Vulcan) to save the planet, but get there too late. The attempt opens up a black hole, dropping Nero and Spock in the past, about 20 something years apart. Spock takes Kirk to a nearby outpost, where they find Montgomery Scott. Spock (the older) shows Scott the formula for transwarp beaming that he won’t invent for 20 years and they use it to get back onto the Enterprise to usurp Spock’s command and take the Enterprise to try to save Earth, now with everyone aware that this is new timeline, with different histories over the last quarter century. In the end, this younger crew find a way to save the day and work as a team doing it. With Pike saved, then promoted, James T Kirk is promoted to Captain and brings on Scotty and Spock, after the younger Spock meets his elder/alternate self. The film ends at the start of a five year mission.
Notes: The last Trek film was Nemesis, which was bad. It had the usual cast of the Next Generation as well as Tom Hardy and Ron Perlman and yet, was bad. So we needed something to be done differently. The cast do well and we get new and interesting interpretations of these classic characters. Everything looks fine, it’s all cool and shiny (we’re going to ignore the lens flares) and the action is amazing and one that level, this is a fun, action oriented sci-fi film with familiar characters. But the problem is, it is called Star Trek and this film is not Star Trek.
Star Trek is thinking sci-fi that looks at universal ideas, or contemporary ideas through a future lens and speaks to the highest ideals of humanity. This doesn’t. That’s not to say it’s a bad film, but it is bad Trek. Where is the intelligent solution, where is the analogue for something we recognise? Where’s the message, where’s the hope? As Trek it’s a 4/10, but outside of that it’s a fun couple of hours that anyone can enjoy. 8/10